Aberfeldy 1989 Connoisseurs Choice Gordon and MacPhail

Aberfeldy 12 Year Old

Had quite a few drams of it at the distillery, finishing the drinks of my companions who weren't really into whisky. Not to insult this malt, but I actually prefer the Dewar blends. Nose: what can I say, light, faint smell of flowers Taste: Smooth and light, not much to tell about this one actually, a bit oily but lack of character

Score 70/100

Aberfeldy 16 Year Old

I didn't get around to writing a review while I still had the bottle, but I love this stuff so much that I wanted to put some thoughts down anyway. Yes, it is only 40% ABV, chill filtered and probably coloured so most people here will give it a pass, but I know what I like and this is it. The aroma is to die for: luscious grape and sweet vanilla...

Score 93/100

Aberfeldy 12 Year Old

The squat bottle makes the whisky look a very inviting dark amber colour and cute red squirrel on the label is a nice touch too. The description on the packaging of this malt purports a heather honey nose, full bodied and rounded and a dry elegant finish with spicy characteristics and a hint of Seville oranges. It pours a much paler amber into...

Score 86/100

Aberfeldy 12 Year Old

Aberfeldy 12 whisky, produced by John Dewar & Sons Ltd, is proudly labelled on the bottle as "The Heart of Dewar's". I've had this bottle # A54438 open for 8 months. I didn't like this whisky at all for the first six months. This is a review and rating of the whisky at 8 months. For the first 6 months I would have rated this 65 pts,...

Score 86/100